• A federal judge in New York has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering over a 2023 Ethereum trade the Justice Department valued at about $25m.
  • It came on a defence motion after the jury deadlocked and a mistrial was declared, so this is a judge’s decision rather than a jury returning a not-guilty verdict.
  • Coverage says the judge found prosecutors had not proved any material misrepresentation, and that the trades did not happen on a regulated market. The filed order itself has not been publicly verified word for word.

In April 2023, two brothers made a series of Ethereum trades that took roughly twelve seconds. It then took the United States government two and a half years to fail to convict them of a crime for it. The ruling that ended the case is a good deal narrower than the headlines around it.

The question most people expected this case to settle, whether exploiting a flaw in somebody else’s automated trading software counts as theft, has not been settled. The judge decided the government had not proved the specific offence it charged. Reporting says she made a point of saying the ethics of the trade were not the question in front of her.

So if you trade on a public , or you run anything automated on one, nothing about what is permitted has changed. What changed is that we now know how hard this type of case is to win, and prosecutors know it too.

What MEV actually is

Start with how an Ethereum transaction gets processed, because the whole case lives inside that process.

When you send a transaction, it does not go straight into the permanent record. It sits in a public waiting area, usually called the mempool, where anybody can see it. Every twelve seconds or so, someone gets to assemble a batch of those waiting transactions into a block and add it to the chain. On Ethereum that person is a , chosen more or less at random from the many thousands who have put up the required stake.

The validator does not just choose which transactions go in. They choose the order. And on a market where prices move with every trade, order is money.

That is what MEV means. Maximal extractable value is the profit available to whoever controls the sequence of transactions in a block, over and above the normal fees. Some of it is harmless. Some of it is not. The best known version is the sandwich: a bot spots a large buy order sitting in the mempool, buys the same asset immediately in front of it, lets the victim’s purchase push the price up, and sells immediately behind it. The bot takes the difference, and the person who placed the original order gets a worse price than they expected.

Those sandwich bots are not charities and they are not a bug in the system. They are an industry, and in 2023 they were running constantly. That matters, because they are the party the government said had been defrauded.

What the indictment said happened

Because validators ordering their own blocks creates obvious temptations, most Ethereum validators outsource the job. Specialist firms build blocks, a middleman service called a relay holds the contents in confidence, and the validator signs off on a sealed block without seeing what is inside it. The relay reveals the contents only once the validator has committed.

According to the Justice Department’s 2024 indictment, the brothers became validators themselves, set up bait transactions designed to attract sandwich bots, and then manipulated that sealed-block process so that they could see the contents early and substitute their own transactions. The bots had committed to trades they could not complete. The brothers, the government said, walked away with about $25m of other people’s positions.

Those remain allegations. They were never tested to a verdict, and the ruling that ended the case does not decide whether they happened.

Why prosecutors called it fraud

Here the American legal machinery becomes the story. There is no federal statute that says “do not exploit a trading bot”. What prosecutors reached for instead was wire fraud, a broad and very old offence that covers schemes to obtain money by deception using electronic communications. Wire fraud needs deception. Specifically, it needs a material misrepresentation: somebody has to have been told something untrue that mattered.

The department’s announcement of the charges, in May 2024, was not written in the register of a technical pleading. Then Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said in the press release that “the Peraire-Bueno brothers stole $25 million in Ethereum cryptocurrency through a technologically sophisticated, cutting-edge scheme they plotted for months and executed in seconds”. That was the government’s framing of its own case at the moment of charging, not a finding by any court, and it reads differently now.

What the judge actually ruled

Spacious and elegant wooden courtroom with empty seats, located in Bern, Switzerland.
An empty wood-panelled courtroom in Bern, Switzerland. The brothers’ case was heard in a US federal court in New York. Photo by Christian Wasserfallen on Pexels.

Judge Jessica Clarke granted what is known as a Rule 29 motion, a judgment of acquittal entered by the court on the basis that no reasonable jury could convict on the evidence presented. It followed a trial at which the jury could not agree on a single count and a mistrial was declared, after which the defence renewed the motion and it was argued in February 2026.

Reporting on the decision says Clarke held that prosecutors had not established a material misrepresentation, and that the trades in question did not take place on a regulated market subject to the relevant prohibitions. We have not been able to read the filed order itself, only the docket and secondary coverage, so treat that phrasing as reported rather than quoted from the court.

The distinction to hold on to is between a finding of fact and a finding about a statute. The court was asked whether the government’s evidence could satisfy the elements of wire fraud. It decided it could not. That is not the same as deciding that nothing happened, and it is not a ruling that the strategy was fair.

The misunderstanding this will create

Within a day of this story landing, you will see it described as a court blessing for “code is law”, the long-running argument that anything a blockchain permits is by definition allowed. The ruling does not say that, and it would be a strange thing for a judge to say.

What it does illustrate, and this is our inference rather than anything the court held, is a structural problem that has dogged every American attempt to prosecute an exploit. Fraud statutes were built around deceiving a person. An automated market maker is not a person. A sandwich bot is not a person. When the counterparty is a piece of software executing its own rules, the thing prosecutors need to prove, that somebody was lied to, is the hardest element to pin down. Expect future charges to lean on computer-intrusion and market-manipulation theories instead.

Why this does not travel to the UK

For British readers, the practical answer is that it does not apply here at all. There is no equivalent English ruling, and the route a UK prosecution would take is different in kind. The Fraud Act 2006 covers fraud by false representation, but it also covers failing to disclose information and abuse of position, and English law separately allows a representation to be made to a machine. The Computer Misuse Act 1990 adds offences of unauthorised access and of impairing the operation of a computer, which do not require anyone to have been deceived at all.

Whether any of that would be charged, let alone proved, on facts like these is untested. What you cannot do is read a New York acquittal as a statement about what is lawful in England. For how UK rules are actually developing, our policy coverage tracks it as it moves.

What to watch

Three things. Whether the Justice Department appeals, which is not established either way in current reporting. Whether the full text of the order becomes publicly available, because the exact reasoning on the “regulated market” point will matter far more to lawyers than the outcome does. And whether the next on-chain exploit case gets charged under wire fraud at all, which is the clearest signal of what prosecutors think they learned here.